Midlands Review of Uncanny

midlandsmovies • November 4, 2025

UNCANNY


Directed by Liam Banks


2025


Superfreak Media


Liam Banks follows up the excellent Run For Your Life! (review here) with a short, sharp horror experience that takes influence from the glut of uncanny, ‘imposter’ horror content across YouTube and gaming currently.


James Podmore plays Jordan, a successful singleton who is looking for love on an online dating platform. After a brief, comical interaction with one lady (played by Run For Your Life! lead Rosie Frost), he connects with Amanda (Rachael Caulton). However, there is something clearly very wrong with Amanda, especially when she finally turns her camera on to reveal a distorted, not quite human façade.


Podmore is great as the confused lead, recognising that something is clearly wrong, but also wanting to give his match the benefit of the doubt. And the script kicks him into action just before he risks becoming a stereotypical horror victim. Similarly, Caulton manages to shine through the layers of special effects and voice manipulation, proving she’s just as effective an antagonist, as she is horror victim.


Banks, who also co-handled script duties with Charlie Brentnall, does an excellent job with the effects here. Playing it safe by keeping Caulton in low light for the most part, the effects on her face look great, even as the film quickly shifts to more of a home invasion style piece.


There are also some neat little ‘did you see that?’ moments, with Amanda placed in the background of scenes; standing out just enough to heighten that uncanny feeling, only occasionally marred by a too-obvious sound design that fills the silence with stingers to make the scares obvious.


Overall, it’s an excellent short. One that continues the streak of high-quality horror productions that Superfreak Media has been delivering. At just 20 minutes, there’s no fat to trim here, delivering a genuinely tense, uncomfortable experience that will keep the Halloween vibes coming.


3.5 / 5


Matthew Tilt

Instagram  https://www.instagram.com/tiltmatthew90/


Watch the full short for free on YouTube below:

Midlands Review of Surfing

By midlandsmovies • May 21, 2026
Duane Adamoli and Harry Clarke’s short film ‘Surfing’ is a charming love letter to Birmingham’s music scene through the lens of a struggling musician.

A battle to behold as Midlands Movies visits upcoming historical epic

By midlandsmovies • May 14, 2026
On a bright Sunday morning at a campsite just off the A52 in rural Staffordshire, you would never have guessed that a run-of-the-mill grass field would soon set the stage for an epic encounter between 15th century armies.

A Day at the Beeston Film Festival

By midlandsmovies • May 13, 2026
As my friend and I walked in The Arc Cinema in Beeston, just outside Nottingham, to attend the Beeston Film Festival we were impressed by the sheer amount of people milling around.

Mansfield Town Film Festival achieves BIFA accreditation

By midlandsmovies • May 12, 2026
The Mansfield Film Festival, which champions working-class voices, has now achieved a national industry recognition, marking a major moment for the town as it continues to redefine itself as a growing cultural hub.
Show More